Frodo’s/Mahdi’s Wisdom and Reasoning

In Tolkien’s appropriation of the 1400 year old Mahdi story, he takes the most crucial aspect of the Mahdi, (his almost super human reasoning skills, and creates Frodo Baggins with it.

Tolkien took the Mahdi’s unquenchable thirst for knowledge and super deductive reasoning and let it shine in Frodo the night he solved the riddle at the walls of Moria. Even Gandalf who is hundreds of years older could not figure it out!?

Since The Mahdi/Frodo is not a prophet or messenger he needs this thirst and desire for knowledge to attain the level of guidance which exceeds that of even some prophets.

Ali the Imam, (the wisest among the disciples of the Prophet) said ” He’s the dissector, …he dissects speech with the utmost precision. “

يقول… باقرا..، ثم قال: ذلك رجل من ذريتي يبقر الحديث بقرا

Tolkien makes Frodo/Mahdi ten times smarter than his companions. This is exactly what the prophet said “…he was given the reasoning power of ten scientists…”

“… يعطي فقه عشرة “

Again, even Gandalf couldn’t solve the riddle at the walls of Moria.